No Herr Bob
Bill made it perfectly clear that this is not a public forum with freedom of speech protections. I did not mischaracterize anything, what he says stands on it's own and is perfectly clear and correct.
Bill Cummings wrote:The Hawk are not a governmental entity. The constitution only protects you from government.
When you clicked on the, "agree" button to log on here you made a contract to waive rights and follow website rules.
I did too. Once again, If the private owner says you can't have a gun in your lunch bucket you waive your 2nd amendment rights at the entrance
as a condition to enter. Does this help you realize how it works? I can always try again with other words.
This is a private forum, as shown by Bill above. If you wan't to continue to lie about freedom of speech here by putting gay men into a censorship pens when they say things you don't like, then you are only proving you really are a fascist. Sieg Heil!
Or is Bill a liar, and this is not a private forum? Is Bill lying that I did not sign away rights when I submitted the agreement at sign up? Either Bill is a huge liar, or you are a huge liar.
Dear Bill, Herr Bob is saying you are wrong.
He seems to believe that this is a public forum with freedom of speech protection, (which would make all of you fascists), not a private forum. Please explain to Herr Bob that this is not a government entity, as you so rightly pointed out, with protected freedom of speech rights as you so clearly stated above. Herr Bob is very confused, please educate him. Your explanation and Herr Bobs censoring actions, are perfectly in alignment. Bob is behaving exactly like someone who owns a private forum. Bob could not legally censor me here with freedom of speech protections. It would be unconstitutional to put a person into a censorship pen if there were actually freedom of speech protections on this site. Bill is clearly correct, and Bob is a lying fraud.
Bob Kuczewski wrote:So to recap, the U.S. Hawks does honor freedom of speech in the long standing tradition of that term (no yelling "fire" in a theater, and proper association between speaker and speech).
No - to recap, you have proven beyond all doubt that you do not honor freedom of speech here. This is why I am in this censorship pen. I did not yell fire. You simply put me into a jail because you didn't like my speech, just like a good little fascist. All freedoms have limitations, and yelling fire in a theatre is such a limitation with the 1st amendment. But this forum doesn't have 1st amendment protections at all. Bill made that clear. You wish to conflate a limitation of the 1st amendment with your fascist, draconian censorship of a minority. Your fascist ploy is obvious, and makes you sound even more like the fascist you are. If you want to oppress a gay man, Herr Bob, on your private forum, that is your right. But you cannot pretend there are freedom of speech protections here, after organizing your cabal to put a gay man into a pen by force, against his free will. Siel Heil!
Bill is correct, and your actions prove he is correct. Your actions would be illegal if freedom of speech protections actually existed on this forum. They do not. Bill is entirely correct.
As the constitutional scholar pointed out in the other thread, anonymity is protected by the 1st amendment, and has a long history of use by the oppressed, such as black americans and gay americans. To claim freedom of speech rights, while at the same time censoring this gay man for executing his 1st amendment anonymity, is a direct violation of the 1st amendment. The reason you can actually do this, is because this is a private forum without freedom of speech protections. Therefore, Bill is entirely correct, and Herr Bob is wildly confused.
Sieg Heil! I look forward to the next Bob show post
Bill: 1
Herr Bob: 0