by Bob Kuczewski » Fri Mar 06, 2015 5:15 am
I think every accident contains a lesson to be learned, but that lesson may or may not be obvious.
I think Rick is right that a father is highly likely to have great concern for the safety and well-being of his children. Yet somehow this accident happened, and the daughter was very fortunate to have survived.
In hang gliding, we're all extremely aware of the danger of launching unhooked. The ongoing arguments on how to best avoid this danger (hang checks, hook-in checks, "Aussie method", hook-in streamers on wires, hook-in signs at launch, "you're always unhooked", lift-and-tug, etc.) serve to bring the issue to our attention. But in paragliding, I am generally unaware of such a strong emphasis on hook-in checking. This may be from a perception that it's difficult to launch a paraglider "unhooked" because it's already doing a "lift and tug" as soon as the canopy comes up. If the pilot isn't properly hooked in, it's generally assumed that the pull of the canopy will quickly make this known (since it's the pilot's weight in the harness that anchors the paraglider to the ground before launch). However, in a tandem operation, the weight of the passenger may mask the fact that the pilot isn't properly hooked in. This might be a contributing cause in this case. But whatever contributed, I agree with Scott that "There is simply NO GOOD REASON for this PG Tandem pilot-in-command to be dead, and his daughter permanently traumatized". I believe the accident is telling us about some aspect of paragliding that was overlooked either specifically in this case or in general throughout the sport.
By the way, here's what I was taught in the two sports. In hang gliding, I was taught to check the "4 C's": Chinstrap, Crotch, Clearance, and Connection (the "crotch" part of that checklist covers the leg loops). In paragliding I was taught to count to 4: One chinstrap, Two carabiners, Three body straps, Four risers). The three body straps check is intended to catch the two leg loops and the chest strap.
Join a National Hang Gliding Organization: US Hawks at ushawks.orgView my rating at: US Hang Gliding Rating SystemEvery human at every point in history has an opportunity to choose courage over cowardice. Look around and you will find that opportunity in your own time.