A collection of Videos about Hang Gliding

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby Bob Kuczewski » Mon Nov 14, 2011 7:32 pm

miguel wrote:Around here, all pilots know how to fly upright. It is part of learning to fly. I have yet to see a pilot that could not fly upright.

In Tad's dream world everyone will aerotow. They will launch in the prone position with wheels and a tight hang strap (because they're already dangling in the prone position). They'll fly their entire flight in the prone position and they'll land on their wheels - in the prone position.

Once you know that, you'll find that Tad is a tad bit easier to figure out ... but just a tad bit!!

Ooops. There's one more thing to know about Tad. If he ever feels you've disrespected him, he'll take pot shots at you and snipe at you whenever he can for the rest of his life. He'll be forever unable to recognize anything good that you might do because the only thing he remembers is how he thinks you've disrespected him. And I say that as someone who appreciates a lot of what he does and writes. But his paper-thin ego is his Achilles heel.
Join a National Hang Gliding Organization: US Hawks at ushawks.org
View my rating at: US Hang Gliding Rating System
Every human at every point in history has an opportunity to choose courage over cowardice. Look around and you will find that opportunity in your own time.
Bob Kuczewski
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 8372
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2010 2:40 pm
Location: San Diego, CA

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby SamKellner » Mon Nov 14, 2011 8:23 pm

:wave:

miguel wrote: You can also move your legs beyond the plane of your body to accentuate the weight shift forces.


Isn't this the reason that the control frame got larger, in glider design? Late '70s, early '80s? Lowering the pilot, to add strability, even when in the prone position.

Legs accentuate forces? I think so, but don't have the formula. :geek:

:wave:
Southwest Texas Hang Gliders
US Hawks Hang Gliding Assn.
Chapter #4
SamKellner
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 1258
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 7:15 pm
Location: SW Texas

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby TadEareckson » Mon Nov 14, 2011 8:25 pm

You are taught to fly upright so you can be ready to land.

So you're taught that if you're not upright you're not ready to land?

When you are learning on a low height training hill, why complicate things by going prone and then upright to land.

When you are learning on a low height training hill, why complicate things by going upright to land?

How about enough to control the glider in all conditions?

Do you know anybody who's learned to control a glider in all conditions?

How many training hills have gaggles?

Not enough - but that's beside the point. I'm just wondering why I so seldom see pilots going upright anywhere to enhance their roll control authority.

You can and will extrapolate that to whatever you want it to..

No I won't. I'll just extrapolate that to mean that a:

a) prone pilot can go faster than an upright pilot; and

b) faster glider has more control authority than a slower glider.

Any disagreement with either of those? Anybody?

In the mean time, check out your friend Noman, landing at McClure.

Can't see anything. But I hope whatever it is it's embarrassing.

Not following the logic here. Training hills are launch, then land.

1. Which is why people like John Seward tend to slam back into the mountain shortly after launch, people like Al Hernandez are half sick with well founded fear prior to and through some of their first mountain flights, and people like Sharon Carr overshoot the LZ and slam into the trees at the end.

2. And if training hills ARE launch, don't turn, and land then I'm wondering why it's so important that training hill students have all of this enhanced roll control authority alleged to come with flying upright.

Around here, all pilots know how to fly upright.

1. Around here, all pilots know that a loop of 130 pound Greenspot is the only acceptable weak link for an aerotowed solo glider and it's purpose is to increase the safety of the towing operation. PERIOD.

2. So I guess none of the pilots around there have bad backs or paralyzed legs.

It is part of learning to fly. I have yet to see a pilot that could not fly upright.

It wasn't part of Chris Starbuck's learning to fly. He broke his back in the days of seated and rebooted to permanent prone mode. And he's got a better record than John Seward who had a heavy upright background.

There have been numerous pilots at McClure who have lost control on final while prone and hit trees; some with hospital time.

1. And they wouldn't have lost control and hit the trees if they were upright because upright pilots have better control authority?

2. And there haven't been numerous pilots at McClure who have lost control on final while upright and hit trees; some with hospital time?

I do not believe in "I am such a great pilot that I would never to what that idiot, pilot y did."

Neither do I. But I tried to make a flying career out of never doing what pilot y did.

You got me there. I know of no one that was taught to fly prone but not upright.

1. See above.

2. Note that it was the opinion of both eyewitness that the subject of this thread died because he was taught to fly upright but not prone.
TadEareckson
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 456
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 9:07 am

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby SamKellner » Mon Nov 14, 2011 8:29 pm

bobk wrote:[ In Tad's dream they will launch in the prone position with wheels.


I was sitting here knowing that's where the discussion was headed. :clap: :thumbup:
Southwest Texas Hang Gliders
US Hawks Hang Gliding Assn.
Chapter #4
SamKellner
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 1258
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 7:15 pm
Location: SW Texas

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby TadEareckson » Mon Nov 14, 2011 10:29 pm

Ummm ... maybe we'd like students to stay upright longer ... so they can survive their valuable air time enough time long enough to actually benefit from it. Sheesh!

Is there somebody out there who can make sense of that and get back to me?

Joe Greblo sends his students off in mild enough conditions where they can fly their whole 10 minute flight in the upright position.

And to think of all the fun I missed on MY first dune soaring, tow, and mountain flights. Oh well, I guess there's no turning back the clock.

I've done that many times at Torrey Pines where I do imaginary landing approaches several hundred feet above the terrain.

That would be wasted on me. I always stay prone into ground effect.

Flying upright is not something to be feared.

I don't fear it - unless I'm near the ground. I just hate it.

It's something to be mastered.

1. Like standup landings. Problem is it seems to be a whole lot easier to find pilots with broken arms than it is pilots who've mastered standup landings.

2. Nobody's ever mastered it enough to fly the glider through its full certification range.

Also, as has been pointed out, the upright position gives very good roll control because there's very little chance of cross-controlling.

Great. The problem I have is that my chance of "cross controlling" has always been zero. And I've always found that to be adequate.

...Just pull yourself in the direction you want to go and your weight will be right there when you need it.

What do I just do if I come into the LZ and the adequate speed allowed by upright isn't adequate enough, the bottom drops out, I freefall down to five feet, and the glider still isn't flying?

Let me quote you again...

Let me quote Shane Nestle again...

Being that John was still very new to flying in the prone position, I believe that he was likely not shifting his weight, but simply turning his body in the direction he wanted to turn. Because his altitude was nearly eye level for me, it's difficult to judge what his body was doing in the turn. And because the turn was smooth throughout, it would make sense that he was cross controlling the turn. It was also supported by Dan's observations.

I think staying upright long enough to safely clear the terrain is a pretty simple and basic idea. It might sacrifice 10 to 30 seconds of that "valuable airtime", but I think the survival rate is worth that sacrifice.

1. At the training hill where John should've been learning how to fly a glider the way he'd need it to fly at Packsaddle by the time you've sacrificed ten seconds you've landed.

Christian Thoreson - 2004/10
Flight School Director - 1990-2004
Lookout Mountain Flight Park

Thus wheel landings, the safest and easiest way to consistently land a hang glider...

Jayne DePanfilis - 2004/11

One of the benefits of tandem aerotow training is the opportunity to launch and land on wheels, every flight.

By the time I was cleared to solo aerotow, I was very proficient at rolling in. In fact, for nearly all my landings since that first solo I've rolled in on twelve inch (training) wheels. Yes, I've been to the training hills and invested time in learning how to land on my feet, but only after I already knew how to fly. Still, I trust the technique I learned first: landing on wheels.

For me, rolling in is the right thing to do. It is the safest way for me to end every flight.

Jim Rooney - 2011/06/12

Most common HG injury... spiral fracture of the humerus.

2. We have not yet established that flying upright has a positive effect on survival rates.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=la7Ym4O38SA

3. I count about four seconds from "Clear" to prone. How much more safely clear of the terrain does anyone need to be before going into deadly prone mode?

It might sacrifice 10 to 30 seconds of that "valuable airtime", but I think the survival rate is worth that sacrifice.

Did you run that thought past John Seward's family?

Once the pilot is clear of the terrain (and can fly an unintentional 360 without hitting anything!!) that might be a good time to prone out and experiment with cross-controlling.

1. I'm thinking that just about all people who fly unintentional 360s should find other recreational activities (preferably ones that don't involve much in the way of motion) - whether or not they hit anything in the process.

2. Yeah, if you haven't yet learned cross-controlling... Always remember - it's never too late to start!

But be careful about listening to everything he says because some of it is just plain wrong...

1. If Zack was the sort of person who just listens to everything somebody says he wouldn't be listening to me - he'd be a card carrying Rooney Follower or Harmonizer.

2. And he's quite capable of figuring out what's just plain wrong or right when I or anybody else walks him through any fine points of the relevant physics. He knows how the check the math.

3. And in any case he knows he's better off with off with me than he was with the 130 pound Greenspot, pin bending zombies who were rotting his brain out before.

In Tad's dream world everyone will aerotow. They will launch in the prone position with wheels and a tight hang strap (because they're already dangling in the prone position). They'll fly their entire flight in the prone position and they'll land on their wheels - in the prone position.

This, of course, is all perfectly true - but you might wanna back it up with an actual quote every now and then so your other readers don't think you're just making stuff up as you go along.

Ooops. There's one more thing to know about Tad. If he ever feels you've disrespected him, he'll take pot shots at you and snipe at you whenever he can for the rest of his life. He'll be forever unable to recognize anything good that you might do because the only thing he remembers is how he thinks you've disrespected him.

Yeah, everyone needs a hobby. I wouldn't recommend this one for everyone but it's always worked great for me.

Oh yeah, that reminds me...

Sam,

I'm guessing that at your high school they had serious shortages of pens and pencils but a huge surplus of yellow crayons?
TadEareckson
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 456
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 9:07 am

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby TadEareckson » Tue Nov 15, 2011 8:38 am

Burn your paraglider so we know your serious

95 percent of the so called "pilots" on that forum ARE total idiots, kermit IS solidly on my list of r*chardheads, and I don't know what's going on behind the scenes but - ya gotta admit - that WAS funny (even if the writing wasn't up to grade school standards).

Check out the amount of real estate used on this forum and tell me it's not the "Tad Show".

1. Posts:

936 - bobk
349 - TadEareckson

2. It looks like the vast majority of you're real person members fall into the zero to one post range.

3. You're welcome.

4. I've always been very careful to leave adequate real estate for anyone else who feels like it to be able to participate.

5. Feel free to come over to Kite Strings and retaliate.

Look "Nobody", I've coddled Tad for nearly a year now...

I can't thank you enough but I'm starting to feel ready to be weaned off at this point.

...and he's still a loose cannon.

No, please - I'm serious.

He's probably one of the biggest reasons that this site hasn't been embraced by many of the pilots who want to see a better version of USHPA.

Enough with the flattery already.

I'm beginning to think that I've wasted my time with Tad and that I'm wasting my time with you as well.

Undoubtedly.

This site is intended to be the basis for forming a new national hang gliding association.

By welcoming one and all USHGA ticket holders with open arms and giving everyone an equal say in policy - regardless of race, ethnic origin, gender, religion, rating, competence, intelligence, education, sanity level, or the number of people one has helped get maimed and killed. Or even if you haven't got a card of any kind.

We welcome everyone who wants to do that...

Yeah. EVERYONE. QUANTITY is what we're looking for here - quality be damned.

But if you're intentionally steering people to a different site and explicitly steering them away from this site, then you are not aligned with our goals.

How many US Hawks members authorized you to speak for them? I didn't sign off on anything and I don't have any problem with anything he's done here. Hell, if he wants to steer people away from here and to the Davis or Jack Shows or the SGAA he should be able to do it. That would certainly pale in comparison to telling people:

Preflight, Hangcheck, Know you're hooked in.

If he steers junglepilot over to the Kite Strings ground school, junglepilot hopefully can come back here as a competent pilot and maybe neutralize some of the r*chardheads you're attracting. Then we'd have a better chance of getting an organization less likely to kill my nephew.

You don't want to participate in building a better national hang gliding association here, and as far as I'm concerned you're no longer welcome.

He's actually doing an excellent job of helping build a better national hang gliding association here - and of helping destroy really rotten associations elsewhere - and as far as I'm concerned he'll ALWAYS be welcome.

Now I am asking you to either participate in trying to build the US Hawks Hang Gliding Association or please go somewhere else.

F. Chapters and its officers are required to be goodwill ambassadors for USHPA and are expected to work within the USHPA committee system to support USHPA's image and support USHPA programs. Chapters cannot on one hand participate in USHPA subsidized programs and on the other take actions which are detrimental to the USHPA and the sport. Examples of actions which may be detrimental are:

1. Any correspondence in any public media which is critical of USHPA's programs and policies.

2. Any correspondence in any public media which is critical of other Chapters.

3. Any Club policy which is detrimental or causes harm to any USHPA program.

Do you understand that?

I sure do. We're trying to build a better version of USHPA and different people have very different concepts of what is meant by "better".
TadEareckson
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 456
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 9:07 am

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby miguel » Tue Nov 15, 2011 12:19 pm

Rather than spending time trying to get the labels [/quote] just right, I will keep this real short.

No problem with Tad, I want to make sure that low time pilots see something besides what Tad writes.

Tad, Instead of hanging with these dudes,
Image

Watch the video:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VtH2qZYWLrA

Don't have the time to go into the rest of it right now. Maybe later
miguel
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 126
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 9:20 am

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby TadEareckson » Tue Nov 15, 2011 1:49 pm

Yeah. His hands are on the basetube all the way down to the surface and stay there while he continues finalling uphill and only come off to go to the downtubes six seconds prior to a touchdown preceded by a rather alarming and unnecessary flare.

So doesn't this support - rather than contradict - what the low time pilots are seeing Tad write?

Now kids, ask yourselves how much worse this guy's landing:



would've been if he had stayed fully prone and zipped up in his pod with both hands on the basetube and the bar held back for most of that clip.
TadEareckson
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 456
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 9:07 am

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby SamKellner » Tue Nov 15, 2011 2:09 pm

No, that's not what the report says.

TadEareckson wrote:2. Note that it was the opinion of both eyewitness that the subject of this thread died because he was taught to fly upright but not prone.

:thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown:

That is really bending the facts about what the report says. IMO, :wave: , a mis-truth, more drivel.

The eye witness making the report is a low time, advanced to H-2 ~ ten years ago, with FL & AT only, probably ten years ago also. I might believe his witnessed accounts, but his opinion should have been left out.

Still, that is NOT what either said in the report.

Nanny, Nanny, won't even fix this type of accidents. USHPA is trying to fix these situations with instructor liability ins. :crazy:

Too much drivel :crazy: . The real problem of why we/Reg11 lost the two beginners is not being addressed.
Southwest Texas Hang Gliders
US Hawks Hang Gliding Assn.
Chapter #4
SamKellner
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 1258
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 7:15 pm
Location: SW Texas

Re: Fatal hang gliding accident

Postby SamKellner » Tue Nov 15, 2011 2:13 pm

TadEareckson wrote:Yeah. His hands are on the basetube all the way down


It's not where his hands are, that makes the difference. It's where his FEET are. Drivel

:wave:
Southwest Texas Hang Gliders
US Hawks Hang Gliding Assn.
Chapter #4
SamKellner
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 1258
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 7:15 pm
Location: SW Texas

PreviousNext
Forum Statistics

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

Options

Return to Hang Gliding Videos