Personal Journals about Hang Gliding

NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lines

Postby Rick Masters » Mon Jan 25, 2016 12:08 pm

In reviewing my accident list, I am struck by the number of hang glider pilots, ultralight pilots, PDMC daredevils and powered PDMC daredevils who fly into power lines and die or get maimed or seriously burned. There is something we could EASILY do about this that has never been done.

All power lines emit an electromagnetic signal. Everyone is familiar with losing a radio signal when passing under power lines. What most people don't realize is the POWER of this signal. You can string a length of wire underneath a power line and get a flow of electricity out of it. (Some folks figured out that they could do this and connect a transformer to the wire to get the voltage they needed to run stuff in their homes, so the utility companies in some states complained and laws were written making the practice illegal!)

So it is obvious to see that the big, high power lines put out a strong signal and the lower power lines emit a less powerful signal. They're all emitting signals that can be easily detected by a simple instrument.

First, what are we looking for? Power lines in our flight path that we don't see. The instrument should be directional, dampening signals from the sides and focusing directly ahead. A manual sensitivity adjustment would allow pilots to calibrate the instrument in the air to provide enough time to turn away from danger while not being a nuisance.

This instrument could save a lot of lives. It could also dramatically reduce the number of rescues and power outages that reflect poorly on the reputation of air sports. This idea is so simple and obvious, we should slap ourselves and ask, "Why didn't we think of this?!"

I would really like to see the folks designing Thermal Snoopers incorporate this into their design.
Last edited by Rick Masters on Mon Jan 25, 2016 1:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Rick Masters
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 3260
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 5:11 am

Re: NEEDED: A proximity indicator for power lines

Postby JoeF » Mon Jan 25, 2016 12:25 pm

:?: Powerline Detection System (PDS)
Year 2007 note: http://www.safeflight.com/powerline-detection-system-recieves-easa-certification/
Safe Flight’s Powerline Detection System is designed to sense from any direction the electromagnetic field surrounding live powerlines. The system warns pilots when their helicopter is in danger by emitting an unmistakable auditory alert. Pilots can literally “hear” their relationship to a powerline hazard, even when they cannot see it. The audio warning increases in frequency (like a Geiger counter) as the helicopter gets closer to a live powerline. A red warning light also illuminates on the cockpit indicator. The Powerline Detection System may be a significant, and potentially life saving advantage when the pilot has not seen the powerline.


Safe Flight Instrument Corporation, founded in 1946 and headquartered in White Plains, NY, pioneered the development of stall warning, angle of attack measurement, automatic throttles, and wind shear warning systems for fixed-wing aircraft. In the helicopter market, Safe Flight produces exceedance warning and powerline detection systems. Safe Flight products are installed on over two-thirds of the world’s aircraft in the general aviation, corporate, commercial, and military sectors.

*While the Powerline Detection System provides a unique warning against this hazard, it does not warn against all powerlines and will not alert pilots of some strike hazards that emit electromagnetic fields.


What has been the progress since 2007?
:arrow: http://www.safeflight.com/products/powerline-detection/
:arrow: Urge by Rick Masters to get powerline detection bundled with thermal snoopers.
:arrow: [ ] Explore what amateur radio buffs have to say about powerline noise
:arrow: http://www.arrl.org/power-line-noise
:arrow: What has been done by militaries to detect wires strewn about the lands?
:arrow: ??????
================================================

Caution: Ever scope areas of one's flight plan. There may be lines that are not powered.
Clubs: Maps of known hazards, lines, powerline, holes, lumpy fields, no-land areas, yes-land-out potential, ...

\==================================================================\
tags: powerline, power line, hazard detection,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_power_line
Join a National Hang Gliding Organization: US Hawks at ushawks.org

View pilots' hang gliding rating at: US Hang Gliding Rating System
JoeF
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 4866
Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 3:41 pm

NEEDED: Simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Rick Masters » Mon Jan 25, 2016 1:39 pm

Image
My favorite boat anchor is this 70-pound Stoddart Radio Company TS-587/U prototype signal strength (field intensity) meter.
It was probably hand-built by Dick Stoddart in 1946 as a late pre-production prototype, as it wasn't given a government serial number.
I found it in the basement of a curio store a few years ago in Bakersfield, California - 120 miles from Hollywood.
Nobody there knew what it was.
I've never turned it on because the old paper capacitors might need to be replaced to avoid damage and I lack the correct power supply.
The tubes are very lightly discolored - such as one might get from testing but not actual use.
It is as mint a boat anchor as I've ever seen.
Actually, I don't know if it qualifies for the term "boat anchor" because it is a scientific instrument, not a typical military radio receiver.
Image
Stoddart had been chosen by Howard Hughes in 1938 to serve as his radio engineer for the second around-the-world heavier than air non-amphibious flight.
On this flight, Dick used an earlier prototype signal strength meter of his own design to locate known transmitters near their global circum-navigational route.
Image
Image
Howard Hughes was so impressed with the success of Stoddart's navigation instrument that he helped set up Stoddart Radio Company in Hollywood in 1940.
Dick won major contracts with the Navy building signal strength meters and receivers for the next 30 years.
Image
The TS-587/U was fitted to a Stoddart RF-36/U tuner. In 1947, it sold for something like $100,000 in today's dollars.
It used a directional antenna similar to these antennas supplied with his popular NM40A audio spectrum receiver (above).
More: http://online.sfsu.edu/hl/src.html
I found a manual for the operation of a Stoddart NM20B that sums up the lessons learned over 20 years of experimentation.
You geeks may find it very interesting.
http://www.militaryradio.com/manuals/Stoddart/Stoddart%20NM20-B%20Instruction%20Manual%20Jan%201960.pdf
If you have to have one, look here.
http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_pgn=1&isRefine=false&_nkw=stoddart%20radio
But I doubt you'll find a TS-587/U.
--------------------------
Howard Hughes completes round-the-world flight in 1938
NEW YORK DAILY NEWS
Image
As soon as plane came to stop, police immediately formed a ring around it. And up go some hands as the cheers start.
July 15, 1938 by Sloan Taylor

How death thrice laid an ambush for Howard Hughes and his four companions in their record-breaking flight around the world, was revealed last night by the young millionaire airman in his own story of his voyage. While 25,000 spectators staged a wild demonstration, Hughes brought his plane to earth on Floyd Bennett Field at 2:34 P.M. yesterday, having girdled the earth in 3 days 19 hours 14 minutes and 10 seconds, and clipped 3 days 23 hours 35 minutes from the record set up by Wiley Post, flying alone in 1933.

To the millions of radio listeners who had followed Hughes’ progress over the Atlantic and then across three continents, the race against time, which began here at 7:20 P.M. on Sunday, had appeared as an almost mechanical fulfillment of the flier’s plans.

Reveals Brushes with Death.

But Hughes’ story revealed that he and his companions had rubbed shoulders with death at the take-off; that they had seen its shadow a second time over the wastes of the Atlantic, and that it had hovered over them again on the Siberian plains.

Overladen, their giant silver monoplane, its motors with 2,200-horsepower roaring at full throttle, lagged behind its flying speed, and almost refused to take the air as Hughes drove it down the Floyd Bennett runway Sunday evening for the Atlantic crossing.

When it had reached a ground speed of 125 miles an hour, and just in time to avoid disaster, its huge wings bore the World’s Fair, 1939 aloft, but its tail wheel was so badly damaged that the French mechanics in Paris despaired of repairing it.

Over the Atlantic, Hughes watched his gasoline gauges with apprehension, as his motors drank their fuel much faster than he had anticipated, and he contemplated the possibility of a forced landing. But the supply held out, and Hughes and his fellow adventurers got to Paris - not, as the officials of Le Bourget airdrome reported, with a surplus of 300 gallons, but with just sufficient petrol to keep the motors going.

A hunch saved Hughes in Siberia, when he deferred from dark until dawn the start of his hop from Takutsk to Fairbanks, Alaska. His maps showed the maximum altitude of the Terkhoisankoi Mountains, over which his course lay, to be 6,500 feet. Their true altitude Hughes discovered was 9,700 feet. Had he not delayed his start until daylight, his plane might now be distributed in wreckage upon some lonely Siberian crag.

“If I’d stuck to my original plan to fly out of Yakutsk, Siberia, by night, I might not be here,” the unshaven, haggard aviator admitted.

“The maps we have show no mountains there higher than 6,500 feet. We measured the mountains as we passed over them the next morning. They were 9,700 feet high, and covered with snow.

Take-off Worst Moment.

“But the most anxious moment of my flight was when we took off from Floyd Bennett Field last Sunday night.

“The plane was too small to carry the load. When I took off, I had to go 125 miles an hour in order to leave the field with 25,600 pounds.

“We had a wing load of forty-seven pounds to the square foot - the greatest wing load I ever heard of, including the Schneider Cup races - and I took off with a 25,600 - pound load, while the most I ever tested the plane at, with water ballast in California, was 24,000 pounds.

“That was why we couldn’t get from Floyd Bennett with less than 125 miles an hour speed. We had to push her up to 175 as soon as we got in the air to make her fly efficiently.

Barely Enough Gas.

“And, as it turned out, there was barely enough gasoline to get us to Paris. Each of the ship’s two engines took forty-five gallons of gas an hour at the start of the flight. But before the end of the trip, I managed to get it down to thirty-two gallons an hour per engine.

“That’s the whole story, that’s the only way that plane could be stretched that far.

“As a matter of fact, there was one more worry. The tail-wheel fittings were damaged by the takeoff, and that pretty nearly ended the flight in Paris.

“ A mechanic at Le Bourget Airport took one look at the wheel and said to me:

“‘C’est fini.”

“But Ed Lun, our mechanic, went to work, and who should appear to help him but a United States Army mechanic named Cook.

“They fixed the wheel with angle irons, and we were able to take off after about eight hours.

“The ocean crossing was easy. We didn’t see a single wave except in Boston Harbor. We didn’t see much over the Atlantic and we just got a glimpse of Ireland through a hole in the fog.

“We made that jump on the instruments - by blind flying. We had to do the same thing on the hop from Paris to Moscow.

“The weather out of Moscow also was thick, but I took the plane up over it. Four or five times, we picked up a lot of ice in high attitude, with no de-icers on the wings. But our anti-ice carburetors were perfect.

“I wasn’t satisfied with the Government maps of Siberia at all and that’s why I didn’t fly out of Takutsk at night.

“The rest of the trip, if you subtract the weather hazards and the drain on our energy, was simple.

“We used three distinct types of navigation - contact dead-reckoning when we could see the ground, celestial when we could see the sun or stars, and radio when the fog closed in.

Few Hours Sleep.

“I didn’t sleep much and neither did the boys with me. We had a few catnaps, but I guess our total for the trip wasn’t more than a few hours each.

“We ate mostly canned goods on the flight. When we were hungry we would open a can and eat. It wasn’t so good, but it was better than nothing.

Hughes was prevented by the crush of welcoming crowds from laying a wreath on the spot at Floyd Bennett Field where Wiley Post landed after his solo flight around the world in the Winnie Mae. The millionaire Magellan expressed regret that he had been unable to make that tribute to the man who later died in a crash with Will Rogers in Alaska.

At Floyd Bennett Field, Howard Hughes slow his 'round-the-world monoplane to a stop, completing his amazing flight. A fence-and police-hold back crowd in foreground while cameramen make ready to snap the five heroes.

At Floyd Bennett Field, Howard Hughes slow his 'round-the-world monoplane to a stop, completing his amazing flight. A fence-and police-hold back crowd in foreground while cameramen make ready to snap the five heroes.

“There’s no use trying to compare this with Wiley Post’s flight. His feat never will be duplicated.

“His flight must still remain the most remarkable in history.

“He did it alone. To make a trip of that kind alone is beyond comprehension. It is like pulling a rabbit out of a hat or sawing a woman in half.

Praise Companions.

“I can’t say too much in praise of the boys who were with me. They all did a great job.

“I had two of the the best aerial navigators that ever lived - Lieut. Thomas Thurlow, inventor of our drift indicator, and Harry Connor, a fine celestial navigator who learned it in the Merchant Marine.

“Ed Lund, the mechanic, watched the engine temperatures and instruments when I rested. Dick Stoddart, the radio engineer, who designed and built the transmitter, did a swell job. It’s the best crew in the world.

“And, I might add, everybody along the line of flight co-operated excellently with us.

“The thing that has pleased me most is that I’ve proved to myself that my route is the best between this country and Moscow.

“I’ve got a complete record of this flight, I’m happy to say. I’ve made up a complete log, about thirty to forty pages long. That may help us when we come to determine the scientific value of this flight. Mechanically, all our equipment was perfect, including the gyropilot.

“Would I like to make the flight again?

“Not on your life. Once is enough.”
Last edited by Rick Masters on Mon Jan 25, 2016 2:14 pm, edited 4 times in total.
Rick Masters
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 3260
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 5:11 am

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby JoeF » Mon Jan 25, 2016 1:54 pm

http://www.myanchorwatch.com/Features/Overview.aspx

==============
PopSciMay1932InventionComment.JPG
PopSciMay1932InventionComment.JPG (46.84 KiB) Viewed 13528 times


----
If we could could use HG airframe as receiver and then have signal interpreted via extant instruments ... then
weight addition might be zero or nearly next to zero.
Join a National Hang Gliding Organization: US Hawks at ushawks.org

View pilots' hang gliding rating at: US Hang Gliding Rating System
JoeF
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 4866
Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 3:41 pm

Re: NEEDED: A cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Rick Masters » Mon Jan 25, 2016 5:06 pm

I don't think it would weigh much at all.
I just want it in the instrument pod so the PDMC daredevils could use it, too.
Rick Masters
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 3260
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 5:11 am

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Harry » Tue Jan 26, 2016 9:21 am

AM radio and a fluorescent light bulb.

Drive under any power line with an AM radio and you will hear the AC buzz. Get close enough and the tube will glow from the free electrons in the air.

Just need to box it up and make it more sensitive. Not a project I'm willing to spend R&D money on. It may alert you to the danger, but you still have to visually spot the wire. This is why some lines have big orange balls to alert low flying helo pilots, and the reason why helicopters have them wire cutters mounted above and below the cockpit.
Harry Martin
Fear is not boring, the stupid shall be punished
Harry
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 68
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2015 7:17 am
Location: Wild and windy Casper, Wyoming

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Rick Masters » Tue Jan 26, 2016 9:39 am

You don't need to spot the wire.
You execute a turn away from danger.
Rick Masters
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 3260
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 5:11 am

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Frank Colver » Tue Jan 26, 2016 1:45 pm

I'm way ahead of you guys.

Many years ago, while working for a small instrument company in Orange CA, I designed a power line warning instrument for cranes (not the bird kind). The detector's antenna ran all the way up the boom so as to give complete coverage at any portion of the boom.

The electric field was detected using the high impedance gate of a mosFET which was one of my early uses of these new (then) devices. The SoCal Edison Company gave me the use of their substation in Santa Ana and a crane operator for initial tests. The device was manufactured and sold for many years and may still be, for all I know (the company has moved to another city). However, my guess would be that it has been replaced by now with newer designs.

When the boom approached a power line a loud alarm sounded plus a flashing red warning light.

The substation was a difficult place for the initial prototype tests because there were so many electric fields present it was difficult to find a spot where the alarm was not continuously going off. :?

Frank C.
Frank Colver
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 1292
Joined: Tue May 24, 2011 11:21 am

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Harry » Tue Jan 26, 2016 2:33 pm

fcolver wrote:...there were so many electric fields present it was difficult to find a spot where the alarm was not continuously going off. :?


The reason why I wouldn't waste my time designing one.
Harry Martin
Fear is not boring, the stupid shall be punished
Harry
User avatar
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 68
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2015 7:17 am
Location: Wild and windy Casper, Wyoming

Re: NEEDED: A simple cheap proximity indicator for power lin

Postby Rick Masters » Tue Jan 26, 2016 4:18 pm

The reason why I wouldn't waste my time designing one.

Because it's too noisy inside a substation?

Image
If you are crashing into a substation, no instrument will help you.
Maybe someone else might be interested.

Image

Since the intensity of electromagnetic emissions is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the source, it seems to me that a device could be built to warn a pilot that he is approaching a power line.

Again, imo, it would have to be directional and have a manual sensitivity adjustment. This would prevent it from being overwhelmed by more distant emissions.
Rick Masters
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 3260
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 5:11 am

Next
Forum Statistics

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 223 guests

Options

Return to Blog Forum